The US Treasury has welcomed a statement released by the Securities and Exchange
Commission and the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board regarding their votes
to address the implementation of Section 404 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act:
"The SEC and the PCAOB, after carefully considering the effects of Section
404, moved this week to strike the right balance in enhancing financial reporting
quality and eliminating unintended costs," announced Under Secretary for Domestic
Finance Robert K. Steel. "These key reforms should ensure that Section
404 is implemented in a risk-based and appropriately-scalable fashion, without
sacrificing investor protection or diminishing the value of sound internal controls
over financial reporting. Now that the regulators have acted, it is critical
that public companies and the auditing profession respond to this call."
Steel added: "Treasury congratulates the SEC, the PCAOB and their chairmen,
Chris Cox and Mark Olson, for their cooperation in working to uphold investors'
confidence in and the competitiveness of America's capital markets."
Last week, the Securities and Exchange Commission unanimously approved interpretative
guidance to help public companies strengthen their internal control over financial
reporting while reducing unnecessary costs, particularly at smaller companies.
The new guidance will enhance compliance under Section 404 of the Sarbanes-Oxley
Act of 2002 by focusing company management on the internal controls that best
protect against the risk of a material financial misstatement.
“Congress never intended that the 404 process should become inflexible,
burdensome, and wasteful. The objective of Section 404 is to provide meaningful
disclosure to investors about the effectiveness of a company’s internal
controls systems, without creating unnecessary compliance burdens or wasting
shareholder resources,” explained SEC Chairman Christopher Cox. “With
the Commission’s new interpretative guidance for management on the evaluation
and assessment of its internal controls over financial reporting, companies
of all sizes will be able to scale and tailor their evaluation procedures according
to the facts and circumstances. And investors will benefit from reduced compliance
costs.”
“Our guidance enables companies of all sizes to focus on what truly matters
to the integrity of the financial statements – risk and materiality,”
added Conrad Hewitt, Chief Accountant. “Providing management with its
own guidance for evaluating internal control over financial reporting will ensure
an appropriate balance between management's evaluation process and the audit
process. While the guidance is intended to help public companies of all sizes,
smaller companies, which will begin complying with Section 404 this year, should
benefit from its scalability and flexibility. We have also worked closely with
the PCAOB to better align our interpretative guidance and the PCAOB’s
proposed auditing standard, which the PCAOB will consider for adoption tomorrow.”
“As investors have made clear, Section 404 serves a critically important
role in fostering the reliability of financial statements upon which investors
and our markets depend. The guidance issued today achieves a significant step
in the roadmap the Commission laid out a year ago for improving the implementation
of Section 404 for public companies of all sizes and their investors alike,”
stated John W. White, Director of the SEC’s Division of Corporation Finance.
He added: “The Commission and its staff have been focused on improving Section 404
implementation for some time, and our efforts have been considerably aided by
the public comment process and helpful insights and suggestions that various
interested persons have provided us. The Commission’s interpretive guidance
should reduce uncertainty about what constitutes a reasonable approach to management’s
evaluation while maintaining flexibility for companies that have already developed
their own assessment procedures and tools that serve the company and its investors
well. Companies will be able to continue using their existing procedures if
they choose, provided of course that those meet the standards of Section 404
and our rules.”
The Commission also approved rule amendments providing that a company that
performs an evaluation of internal control in accordance with the interpretive
guidance satisfies the annual evaluation required by Exchange Act Rules 13a-15
and 15d-15. The Commission additionally amended its rules to define the term “material
weakness” as “a deficiency, or combination of deficiencies, in internal
control over financial reporting, such that there is a reasonable possibility
that a material misstatement of the company's annual or interim financial statements
will not be prevented or detected on a timely basis.”
The Commission further voted to revise the requirements regarding the auditor’s attestation report
on the effectiveness of internal control over financial reporting to more clearly
convey that the auditor is not evaluating management’s evaluation process
but is opining directly on internal control over financial reporting.
The effective date of the interpretive guidance and adopted rules will be 30
days from their publication in the Federal Register.
The new auditing standard will be subject to Commission approval in the coming
months after its adoption by the PCAOB and, if approved, is expected to be effective
no later than for calendar year 2007 audits, with early adoption encouraged.